Candidates and Constituency Assessments


saltire shield'On February 23 Dunfermline West Labour MSP Scott Barrie told The Courier, "It is disappointing, if it is true, that tolling will remain only on the Forth and the Tay bridges. We have seen half the tolled bridges freed. Why is it only Fife that has to pay?"
Yesterday he voted to keep the tolls on the Tay.'
The Courier 31 st March 2006.
Lion Rampant

Dunfermline West (Mid Scotland & Fife Constituency)

Candidates

Who Susan Archibald
(Number 2 on Mid Scotland & Fife list)
Scottish Voice
Scottish Voice
Susan Archibald is a campaigner for the disabled.

Recent electoral experience
Scott Barrie MSP Thomas Scott Barrie MSP
(Not standing on Mid Scotland & Fife list)
labour logo
Labour
Scott Barrie was born on the 10 th of March 1962 in Saint Andrews and educated at Auchmuty High School in Glenrothes, Edinburgh University where he graduated with an MA, Stirling University where he obtained a CQSW (Social work) and Dundee University where he obtained a Diploma in Child Protection Studies. He worked with Fife Regional Council from 1986 until 1990 as a social worker, from 1990 until 1991 as a senior social worker, and from 1991 until 1996 as a team manager. From 1996 until his election in 1999 he worked as a team leader with Fife Council. He is single and is a member of UNISON (formerly NUPE). In the parliament he is Convener of the Edinburgh Airport Rail Link Bill Committee and Deputy Convener of the Cross-Party Group on Children and Young People. In his spare time, he is an avid fan of "the Pars" (Dunfermline Athletic) and a season ticket holder at East End Park. He is a keen hill walker and enjoys popular music, citing "The Clash" and "The Smiths" as his favourite groups.

Labour Party positions
- February 2007 - Chief Whip of the Labour Party

Ministerial positions
None

Recent electoral experience
2003 Scottish Parliament election, Dunfermline West, 8,664 votes (34.33 %) (elected)
1999 Scottish Parliament election, Dunfermline West, 13,560 votes (44.21 %) (elected)
Peter Lyburn Peter Lyburn
(Also number 5 on Mid Scotland & Fife list)
Con logo
Conservative & Unionist
Peter Lyburn was born at Ninewells in Dundee and educated at Strathallan School and Edinburgh University where he is studying Agriculture. He has also worked on the family farm at Coupar Angus ad at the Scottish Parliament. He is a member of the Tuesday Club, a Tory 'think tank' and also plays football and golf. In January 2007, on the day David Cameron visited Scotland, Peter Lyburn attacked the leadership of Annabel Goldie, telling BBC Good Morning Scotland: "I'm not being overly controversial in stating that what the party needs is a rejuvenation in leadership." and added: "Not necessarily somebody younger - somebody with a slightly more youthful attitude towards politics."

Recent electoral experience.
Cllr James Tolson Cllr James Tolson
(Not standing on Mid Scotland & Fife list)
liberal logo
Liberal Democrat
Jim Tolson was born on the 26 th May 1965. He has been a member of the Lib Dems since 1989 and was elected as a Cllr in 1992. He is married.

Recent electoral experience
2003 Scottish Parliament election, Dunfermline West, 3,636 votes (14.41 %)
2003 Fife Council election, Garvock & Carnegie, 898 votes (50.31 %) (elected)
1999 Fife Council election, Garvock & Carnegie, 1,351 votes (59.28 %) (elected)
1997 Westminster Parliament election, Dunfermline East, 2,164 votes (5.92 %)
1995 Fife Council election, Dunfermline Garvock, 683 votes (54.12 %) (elected)
1992 Dunfermline District Council election, (elected)
Len Woods Len Woods
(Not standing on Mid Scotland & Fife list)
SNP logo
Scottish National Party
Len Woods has been campaigning against the Labour/Liberal plans to downgrade Queen Margaret Hospital in Dunfermline. In February 2006 he asked Catherine Stilher MEP: 'Up until 2010, a pregnant woman in Fife has the choice of a birth at home or a trip to the Victoria in Kirkcaldy. After 2010, she has the choice of a birth at home or a midwife-led situation at Queen Margaret, with complicated cases going to the Vic. Is this an acceptable situation in modern day society?'. Catherine Stihler believed that it was and she lost the by-election.
In September 2006, he slammed the Labour / Liberal Democrat coalition for the lack of interest they are showing in high profile policing in West Fife. He asked "If we have 600 police officers available throughout Fife, why do we have just 3 officers at any one time covering the West Fife villages and no more than a handful on duty in Dunfermline ?" He added: "People want high profile policing. Not policing on the cheap and not, as a Labour councillor suggested recently, some security company providing 'protection' for which every resident pays an extra charge. That sounds like a mafia approach and not that of a civilised society."

Recent electoral experience

Constituency profile

Assessment:

This assessment is based on the 2003 election results

Rank on Scottish National Party hit list: 21 (33 in 2003)
Swing required for Scottish National Party gain: 8.47 % from Labour to Scottish National Party

Rank on Liberal Democrat hit list: 7 (9 in 2003)
Swing required for Liberal Democrat gain: 9.96 % from Labour to Liberal Democrat

Rank on Conservative hit list: 29 (41 in 2003)
Swing required for Conservative gain: 13.47 % from Labour to Conservative

Correlation to the new Westminster constituencies

The electorate of 53,999 was split between the new Westminster constituencies of:
Dunfermline & West Fife: 53,999 (100.0 %)

Local Government wards in the constituency

Council Ward number Ward name Electorate (June 2001)
Fife 1Kincardine, Culross and Low Valleyfield3,231
2Blairhall, High Valleyfield and Torryburn3,497
3Oakley, Saline and Steelend1 3,462
4Cairneyhill, Carnock and Milesmark3,690
5Crossford and Dunfermline Central3,590
6Baldridgeburn3,668
7Wellwood and Headwell3,605
8Townhill and Bellyeoman3,473
9Garvock and Carnegie3,661
10Halbeath, Hill of Beath and Kingseat13,340
11Woodmill3,232
12Linburn3,349
13Brucefield and Nethertown3,669
14Pitcorthie3,419
15Limekilns and Pitreavie3,914
16Rosyth West3,422

1 Mostly Dunfermline West, some Dunfermline East

Previous results

1 st May 2003 Holyrood Election - Constituency result

Electorate 54,385 (Reported as 53,915 in the press). Turnout 25,240, 46.41 % (- 11.33 %)
Logo Party Candidate Votes % % change
Labour logo Labour Scott Barrie MSP 8,664 34.33 % - 9.88 %
Local Health Concern Independent Campaign for Local Hospital Services David Wishart 4,584 18.16 % (+ 18.16 %)
SNP logo Scottish National Party Brian Goodall 4,392 17.40 % - 10.44 %
Liberal logo Liberal Democrat James Tolson 3,636 14.41 % - 3.82 %
Raving Nutter Conservative & Unionist James Mckie 1,868 7.40 % - 2.32 %
SSP logo Scottish Socialist Party Andrew Jackson 923 3.66 % (+ 3.66 %)
Ind Independent Alastair Harper 714 2.83 % (+ 2.83 %)
Ind Independent Damien Quigg 459 1.82 % (+ 1.82 %)
Labour hold Labour majority 4,080 16.16 % - 0.21 %

1 st May 2003 Holyrood Election - Regional list result

Electorate 54,385. Turnout 25,211, 46.65 %
144 rejected ballot papers
Logo Party Votes % % change
Labour logo Labour 7,264 28.98 % - 11.77 %
SNP logo Scottish National Party 4,203 16.77 % - 8.79 %
Liberal logo Liberal Democrats 3,380 13.48 % - 1.32 %
Health Fighting Hospital Closures & Downgrading 2,358 9.41 % (+ 9.41 %)
Con logo Conservative & Unionist 2,299 9.17 % - 1.90 %

Save Local Hospitals - Dunfermline, Perth, Stirling 1,572 6.27 % (+ 6.27 %)
Scot Green logo Scottish Green Party 1,472 5.87 % + 2.40 %
Scot Soc logo Scottish Socialist Party 1,049 4.18 % + 2.77 %
Pensioners Pensioners's Party 688 2.74 % (+ 2.74 %)
UKIP UK Independence Party 242 0.97 % (+ 0.97 %)
Soc Lab logo Socialist Labour Party 214 0.85 % - 0.44 %
Ind Damien Quigg, Independent 206 0.82 % (+ 0.82 %)
Christian Ind All Christian Independent Alliance Upholding Community Values 137 0.55 % (+ 0.55 %)
Ind Tom Gray, Independent 85 0.34 % (+ 0.34 %)
SPA Scottish Peoples Alliance 42 0.17 % (+ 0.17 %)
Lab logo Labour majority 3,061 12.21 % - 1.87 %

6 th May 1999 Holyrood Election - Constituency Result

Logo Party Candidate Votes % % change
Labour logo Labour Scott Barrie 13,560 44.21 % - 8.87 %
SNP logo Scottish National Party Cllr Douglas Chapman 8,539 27.84 % + 8.67 %
Liberal logo Liberal Democrat Elizabeth Harris 5,591 18.23 % + 4.61 %
BNP logo Conservative & Unionist James Mackie 2,981 9.72 % - 2.92 %
Labour win Labour majority 5,021 16.37 % - 17.54 %

6 th May 1999 Holyrood Election - Regional list result

Logo Party Votes %
Labour logo Labour 12,493 40.75 %
SNP logo Scottish National Party 8,175 25.56 %
Con logo Conservative & Unionist 3,395 11.07 %
Liberal logo Liberal Democrats 4,538 14.80 %
Scot Green logo Scottish Green Party 1,064 3.47 %
Scot Soc logo Scottish Socialist Party 432 1.41 %
Soc Lab logo Socialist Labour Party 396 1.29 %
Pro Life Pro Life Alliance 96 0.31 %
Nat Law logo Natural Law Party 68 0.22 %
Lab logo Labour majority 4,318 14.08 %

1 st May 1997 Westminster Election

Logo Party Candidate Votes %
Labour logo Labour Rachael Squire MP 19,338 53.08 %
SNP logo Scottish National Party John Lloyd 6,984 19.17 %
Liberal logo Liberal Democrat Elizabeth Harris 4,963 13.62 %
Con logo Conservative & Unionist Kevin Newton 4,606 12.64 %
Referendum logo Referendum James Bain 543 1.49 %
Labour hold Labour majority 12,354 33.91 %

Links


Return to home page